The Ultimate Payola. And the next contestant is… not me!
Thursday, October 29th, 2009
I don’t enter music contests. Whenever I hear about them, they crack me up. I can’t believe how exploitative they can be. They play on the archetypal insecurities of unknown artists, counting on the fact that a profitable number of them would be willing to buy a chance at legitimacy, as if legitimacy actually exists. In my view, either you make your expression, or you don’t. The legitimacy of it has nothing to do with what happens after, though the truth of that contention is something of which even I must remind myself from time to time.
Most contests for musicians or songs promise the chance for some notoriety, some brush with stardom, in return for your best effort and your entry fee. I gather that there are still an overwhelming number of “unsigned” recording artists that believe being noticed by some faceless yet “important” individual (any one will do) is one of many paths to success. I haven’t thought that way since I was a kid. It’s a fool’s errand. In this age of independent avenues, the idea is about as viable as a new development that improves the steam engine.
It never sits right with me when people running one of these contests think nothing of placing the distinction of expertise in the hands of some B-level celebrity and deeming them qualified to judge. The contests themselves amount to little more than commercials for everyone other than the people paying entry fees. One example of this practice is the John Lennon Songwriting Contest. It never impresses me when someone describes himself as a “Two-Time John Lennon Songwriting Contest Winner!” Among the judges this year?
The Bacon Brothers.
Huh? What exactly would it mean if the Bacon Brothers thought you were a winning songwriter? I have no idea. The $30 entry fee might get you the answer.
Trust me, no one’s looking for “new talent.” Save your money. It’s not a ticket to anything. You don’t have to be a genius to do a little arithmetic and know that the entry fees add up to a great big profit for the contest. They will never be out-valued by the prize packages.
The Ultimate Payola
I saw this video this week.
This interview could be applied very much to the way it seems like music is treated in the consciousness of the “new” media. I’ve written before about morons who believe music should be free and how these people maintain that there’s plenty of money in licensing for TV and so on. One thing I didn’t think of while writing that piece was that big corporations, the ones who would supposedly have deep enough pockets to license music and keep all of these recording artists and songwriters afloat, are the undisputed pros when it comes to staying rich and not spending their own money. They will fleece you faster than any kid with a high speed internet connection. Of course they will! Stay with me, because thanks to Sirius/XM and Mel Karmazin, I can see where these free music arguments lead: to the Ultimate Payola. I’ve included a link in case you don’t know what payola is.
Yesterday I got my regular spam as a Sirius/XM subscriber (a status I really must reconsider the merits of, truth be told) and it led me to see something so horrible, so criminal and so disgusting that I couldn’t not share it here. Upon reading it, I felt the same revulsion I felt when my Catholic high school religion teacher without prior warning showed a video of an abortion in progress. Yeah, that bad. It’s the Ultimate Payola. This is how bad Harlan Ellison’s contention has gotten with respect to music. I don’t want to believe this is legal, but I’ll never enter, so at least it can’t happen to me.
It seems that this guy Jay Thomas, has a show on Sirius/XM. I had to look up who he was. I think I’ve seen him before, but he doesn’t come to mind when I think “star.” There’s no way this guy could be relevant on any level. Anyway, he’s got this contest going in which he’s searching for the next “Homegrown Song.” “Oh Christ,” I thought, “I’ve gotta see this. How lame.”
But it isn’t lame. It’s sinister.
With a contest pitch, I always look for the entry fee. I was looking for a good laugh on this one, since the prize is only $500. There wasn’t an entry fee, but there was an affidavit you had to sign. An affidavit? Not an entry form. An affidavit.
You don’t have to read it if you don’t want to. They’re hoping you don’t. What could it possibly say that would sway you from the possibility of having your song heard by “thousands and thousands of people?”
I’ll tell you.
As usual, you can’t use their logo, name etc. to promote yourself at all if you win. You can only mention it incidentally. If they play your tune, you’ll never be compensated. No royalties. However, they can do whatever they want with your song, name, image etc. including whatever alterations and even over-dubs they want. There are tons of other clauses for corporate protection there too…
…but I never expected this:
Assignment:
I understand and agree that all rights, title and interest, including the copyright in and to the Entry Recording and all elements thereof and intellectual property rights therein will automatically be assigned to Sponsor upon submission of the Entry Recording, that Sponsor shall own the copyrights and other intellectual property rights relating to my Entry Recording, including the rights to make derivative works, and the Programming (defined below), in any and all present and future media. I understand that my signature on this Affidavit shall effect the assignment.
You know what this is? It’s a transfer of your copyright upon submission. You don’t even have to win! If you submit your song, it belongs to the sponsor! There are already 5 submissions on the site. I wonder if those people know that they no longer own the rights to their songs.
This is how the media industries play. This should not have surprised me. If the free music fallacy is allowed to proliferate, this is what will happen next. Hell, it’s already happening on some small scale. Then what? I can’t decide whether this is worse than some miscreant college kid ripping off thousands of songs by download. Thankfully, I don’t have to decide. They each are their own flavor of evil.
Therefore, the next time you hear someone saying music should be free and that the exposure is all you should care about, tell that person the following in the clearest possible language:
-
Fuck off.
-
I’ll see you in Hell, you scumbag.
-
Allow me to show you a video of an abortion in progress so that you might better understand how I feel about your ill-formed opinion.
Over the top? Maybe, but I had no choice. Harlan Ellison set the bar pretty high.
