No Female Band Members
Wednesday, July 9th, 2008
I know it sounds thoroughly unenlightened, but I’m against female band members. My conviction has nothing to do with their abilities as musicians, though I’ve worked with fewer adequate female players than male. My position concerns human nature. As a songwriter and performer, it’s pretty reasonable to desire some recognition for the hard work that I do. The fact is however that if there’s woman in your band, it doesn’t matter what she’s doing, she’s getting special attention. Exactly what does that do for me as I try to sell records?
Think of any group that had a female member. Did the guys in the band, regardless of how talented they were, get the same attention? Absolutely not. My favorite example is No Doubt. Do you even know the names of the other members? Neither do I. Do people speak as highly of Dave Stewart as they do of Annie Lennox? No. The only thing that saved Fleetwood Mac was that there were two women to kind of balance things. Name a male member of Heart. I can’t do it either. Exceptions that prove the rule are Sly and the Family Stone and The Revolution. You have to be as ostentatious as Sly with fairly unattractive women, or like Prince, more woman than those in your band will ever be, to get by this attention struggle.
Jeff Beck was touring with this female bass player named Tal Wilkenfeld. You might think that anyone who cared enough to want to see Jeff Beck might be immune to the female distraction problem, since after all, you have to dig Jeff for his musicianship. That’s all there is to his act. But no. The video footage of the tour kept going back to the girl and the internet was full of speculation about who she was and how bright her musical future must be. My response to Tal was that tone is in your hands, and that it’s lame to let your amp do all the work. No one ever would have thought twice about a young guy who only switched to bass from guitar five years ago. He just would have been considered lucky to be playing with Jeff Beck, case closed. But the girl? Oh she’s pretty too! Please. Never fails.
I broke the female band member rule once. It was in my first true original band. I was about 19 or so. I had a big group with a horn section. I was trying to find any horns that would play in a rock band and was taking anything I could get to see my vision through. A young woman who played saxophone called me after seeing a flyer we posted at Morris County College. Her name was Martina. I hesitated. I asked her what key I should write her charts in. She said that she played tenor but I shouldn’t worry about re-writing the alto charts because she could sight transpose. Sight transpose? If there was ever a reason to make an exception, this was it.
As it turned out, Martina couldn’t sight transpose. We didn’t get to play any gigs with her, but many of the guys in the band talked a lot about who was going to try to get with her. They just couldn’t get around the primal grunt she would make when she was recording horn hits. Since she was the only one overdubbing a part and the music was only in her headphones, everyone in the room listened to her playing those short little notes, each one of them followed by a soft “uh.” It drove them crazy.
A few guys in the band went out one night and got drunk with Martina, who as I understand was still coherent enough to beg them not to tell me about how drunk she got. Why? I have no idea. All I wanted was to have my charts played. That never really happened to my satisfaction. Did she get thrown out? No. Why? Because she was a really wild chick who would show up at rehearsal fresh from an evening at the Limelight, wearing a purple wig and clothes lifted from a Salvation Army bin in the dead of night, and some guys in the band, who had a say in the membership, were trying to figure out who would get with her. See what I mean?
So as I peruse ads looking for band members or bands to play with, it’s an easy filter. All I have to see is “female fronted band” or “female singer/songwriter looking…” and I know that I can move on. People will never see anyone on stage next to a woman as anything but a sideman, even if he does all the work. And that’s just not enough for me. My wife asked if I would ever let our daughter hear me say that. My response was that she probably would. She was afraid it would discourage our daughter from music. On the contrary, I told her. If our daughter chose music as a vocation, being a woman could only help her. She’ll never have to fight for attention like the guys will. And for her, I said, I’d break the female band member rule without even thinking.



