Random Memoir 4: The church, rock and roll and the fallible priest
From a very early age, I was infatuated with rock music. I had the biggest record collection of anyone in the kindergarten. I loved Kiss and the Eagles and later, groups like Hall and Oates, The Police and Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band. Though I’m not a Catholic anymore, I had my fill of it as a kid, receiving my sacraments, attending 13 years of Catholic school and when I was still young enough to be forced, going to mass on Sunday. It’s amazing how even at the earliest ages, I was using rock and roll as reference point in my life, even in church.
When I was 5 or 6, in my mind, I always compared the altar and congregation at church to the stage and an audience. Daydreaming about my musical heroes was a great way to get through the dreaded Sunday morning rituals. My church had a microphone on a stand like Paul Stanley used. They had what I thought were really cool gray PA column speakers mounted in the choir loft. You’d hear them pumping out the sound of the organ, which would play when we reached that point in the show. The altar had a backstage area called the Sacristy that you needed a connection to get into. In the 70s, our church also had a felt banner behind the altar that took up the entire wall. It usually had a stylized depiction of a biblical scene and a quote. It was really progressive for a Catholic church as I understand them now and it didn’t last, but that was an important part of their stage set. The felt banners were always designed with earth tones, browns and oranges. Christ, even the sanctuary carpet was orange.
Masses also had the audience participation you find at rock and roll shows. People would answer in unison when prompted by the priest. He’d hold his arms up to the heavens periodically, reciting some prayer while the folds in his elaborate costume hung loosely, forming a rough silhouette of wings. In those days, rock stars were superheroes to me. Though the priests weren’t, they got my attention with their histrionics too. Since I got so used to seeing them from the pews, I felt just as removed from them as Kiss.
However, for all the ways in which the showmanship of the Catholic mass worked on my psyche throughout my childhood, it never prepared me for the fact that priests were human. I learned that when I became part of the corps of altar boys in the fourth grade. Though I never experienced any molestation at the hands of a priest, which is so fashionable now, these guys could still be really creepy when you saw them up close. Sunday after Sunday, I sat twenty rows back spending at least an hour looking at these guys, but when I got finally got close enough to the show as an altar boy, the oddness of these characters fueled a very cautious curiosity and a fair amount of confusion.
Father Al, the altar boy director, was the youngest priest in our parish. He was probably creepy before Holy Orders, but by the time we met him, he’d kicked it up more than a few notches. He wore glasses and had a serious comb-over that seemed almost to compliment his crooked front tooth. His hands were the most delicate I’d ever seen on a man. They showed no signs of hard labor and the nails were perfectly rounded. When we poured water over his hands during mass, he moved his fingers very differently from the way my old man would when he washed up at the kitchen sink. Even at ten years old, I could sense that he was in conflict with my idea of what a man was.
Al was definitely the archetypal “holier than thou” priest type. He spoke often of his mother, who routinely embroidered new vestments for him at the change of the church seasons. Al was sure to tell you when he was donning the handiwork of his mother, who no doubt deserved some of the blame for Al’s somewhat condescending and self-righteous nature. He embraced all the ceremonial pomp a Catholic priest could get away with. All of them had to say the same things to celebrate a mass, but every priest had a different style. Al’s style was to chant every prayer he possibly could, lengthening the mass easily by twenty minutes or more. I suppose it was his right, but it even got on my mother’s nerves. We always knew we were in for it when Father Al came parading up the aisle with his girly hands held high. We knew there was no way we were getting home by lunchtime.
Al’s sanctified veneer first weakened at the church fair. They had a Pac Man machine, which of course was very exciting for the kids. When we all left the machine unattended to go off and scrounge for more quarters, Al took it. He was so into his game that the force with which he worked the joystick moved the entire machine. It wasn’t a violent motion but an over-exaggerated, deliberate one that caused the machine walk corner to corner, alternating on its rubber feet. That unnecessary intensity creeped me out and confused me. That kind of ill-founded passion for a video game never came from the adults we knew, let alone from the priests, so it seemed misplaced, and quite suspect. Is he a man? A kid? A priest? The answers were all “No.”
My memory of Al as a pathetic little man was pretty much cemented on my first and last altar boy trip to the Jersey shore. I don’t know what I was thinking at the time, but I think of Al as pathetic now. All of the altar servers, ranging from fourth to eighth grade (and some older, now that I think of it), were packed into two yellow school buses on a summer day, tooling down the Garden State Parkway bound for Seaside Heights. I was probably 10. I was in the middle of the bus. I was not sophisticated enough to be in the back, where presumably you could elude the watchful eye of the driver and chaperones and do cool things like make obscene gestures at cars following behind the bus.
I was gazing out the window, lost in my thoughts as I churned with anxiety about what the day would bring. Then the eighth graders started making some ruckus about girls in a car behind us, flashing their breasts. I couldn’t see anything, but apparently neither could Father Al, who with a giddy smile and wild eyes bombed down the center aisle of the bus to get to the back window.
I couldn’t sort it out at first. I wasn’t allowed out of my seat, but this guy could not only move about freely, but completely forget himself and act like an overgrown adolescent. Even then, I knew he was a hypocrite, though I’m not sure I knew the word for it. This guy, who had boundless energy for browbeating alter boys in training about genuflecting, holding his damn prayer book, ringing bells and handling the Eucharist was actually just a boob man. At that age, I would’ve really enjoyed seeing a pair of boobs, but my experience was confined to being insulted by the phony that old Al turned out to be.
I suspected every priest of being full of shit after that. I still got into the microphones and columns speakers in church from a purely technical point of view, but the pious behavior of the priests became an act that I felt I was always seeing through.
Eventually, I learned that many rock stars were just doing their act too. Some of them even started to look foolish to me. My old man turned out to be human (Never saw that one coming, even when he warned me…), but at least he was never doing an act. When I recognized these truths about life, I never felt like I’d been had. I only felt a little wiser. With Al, I definitely felt like I’d been played for a fool.


